Your local news source ::
      Look for your community »


search chicagomedia kitdiningroger ebertobitssudokucrosswordLotteryhoroscopesyellow pagescenterstagevideoblogstv listings


VIDEO ::   MORE »

TOP STORIES ::
Fame puts squeeze on family life

Dow reaches first close above 12,000

Brown's season in peril

'Maladies' a Cinderella tale

Stuck on you: Piercings can lead to bad hookups

BLOGS ::
Zambrano for A-Rod? No way The Game Of The Year Hotel Valley Ho, Scottsdale, Az. Black Holocaust Survivors? Friday's column: Breast-feeding is the new labor Bush: U.S. "does not torture." Signs new law for treatment of detainees.


Real scandal is state's inability to pay bills

September 23, 2006
Gubernatorial campaigns, especially in Illinois, tend to be divisive. It seems like almost daily voters are bombarded with another scandal, real or imagined. In this election, alleged job scams and pending federal investigations have become as commonplace as baby-kissing. Then there's the constant, counter-accusations between Gov. Blagojevich and state Treasurer Judy Baar Topinka over which of these two candidates for governor is most like the state's recently convicted former governor, George Ryan.

But this focus on scandal and insinuation really doesn't offer much substance. It also distracts voters from the crucial, substantive points upon which all three candidates for governor (yes, three: Green Party candidate Rich Whitney made it onto the ballot) agree, that Illinois needs to enhance school funding and pay its bills on time, but can't, because the state is broke.

Two candidates, Topinka and Whitney, explicitly recognize the problems caused by the state's deficit. Topinka sets the deficit amount at $3.1 billion, citing Comptroller Dan Hynes as her source. She then proposes to raise revenue to fill this gap, and make a significant new investment in education, by creating a high-end, land-based casino in Chicago, and cutting $2.9 billion from anticipated Medicaid growth. Whitney acknowledges the same $3.1 billion deficit as Topinka, but rather than reducing Medicaid or relying on gambling, he proposes comprehensive tax reform, so Illinois will have the ongoing revenue needed both to eliminate the deficit and implement school funding reform.

Blagojevich doesn't explicitly recognize the state's deficit with words, but implicitly acknowledges its existence through actions. In the current fiscal year, the Illinois tax system failed again to produce enough revenue to maintain last year's public services, plus make the full contribution owed to the public employee pension systems, plus pay private health-care providers for all Medicaid services delivered to low-income residents. To avoid painful cuts to needed services, the administration created a budget that underfunds the required pension contribution by $1.1 billion; defers into next year at least $1.7 billion in Medicaid reimbursements to health-care providers this year, and sweeps $200 million from dedicated funds to support general operations. Add that together, and voila, you get $3 billion -- almost the exact same deficit as Topinka and Whitney. Realizing tax revenue won't do the job, Blagojevich proposes selling or leasing the Lottery to fund his education plan.

Without some fundamental reform, be it a recurring revenue increase or significant spending cuts, the state's financial picture will worsen. The chart shows how the deficit will grow over the next five years. The calculation simply adjusts current revenues and current public service costs by inflation (using the consumer price index) and population growth, assuming the economy grows by 4 percent annually. Revenue growth is then compared to cost growth to see whether the deficit increases. Without a change in law, the state's deficit is likely to double.

As the state's fiscal condition deteriorates, economic trends indicate the demand for public services will grow. A recent University of Illinois at Chicago study concluded that year-round workers increasingly rely on public assistance to make ends meet, because their wages are ''too low to support families.'' Illinois has a shortage of affordable housing, transit funding issues, declining incomes and an inadequate, unfair school funding system. Not to mention that 15 percent of the state's workers lost their private employer-provided health insurance over the last 15 years, which will push more working families to seek public assistance in obtaining health care.

Now, I enjoy reading about a good political scandal as much as the next guy. But the seminal issues confronting Illinois are its fundamental inability to pay its bills, satisfy growing demand for services and reform how it funds schools. This election season, the candidates and voters would be better served with a break from the sensational, and a focus on the meaningful.