Front-page coverage of our growing, unrealistic commute
times once again reflects our reliance on mass transit in our
region for our quality of life ("The pay’s fine, but how's the
drive?" Page 1, June 11). To the region's detriment, transit
has relied on a 24-year-old funding formula, which has not
grown with population, at a time when federal operating
dollars were eliminated. Our quality of life will further
diminish if an adequate and fair transit-funding package does
not emerge from Springfield at the end of this month.
The good news is that negotiations in Springfield revise
the transit funding formula to reflect the region's needs
today, restoring fiscal health and setting it on a course for
improvements and growth. Only two hurdles remain: the
governor's signature and a resolution to funding the CTA
pensions.
It's time for Governor Blagojevich to sign the new
legislation into law - regardless of his no-new-tax pledge.
This is a good deal for the region and the state; it can
relieve congestion in the region and facilitate the movement
of goods to other parts of Illinois and the country. Our
legislators worked all session to identify adequate funding
sources, specifically relatively small increases in the sales
and real estate transfer taxes, all viable options contained
in the act governing the RTA. No other revenue proposal was
offered. Finally RTA's new powers under the legislation will
offer greater coordination among transit services, new
resources to relieve congestion by making road improvements
and funding available to improve suburb-to-suburb commuting.
Inadequate funding for transit over the last 25 years has
not only diminished travel, but has led to unfortunate
decisions regarding the CTA employee pension fund which is now
only 39.4 percent funded. In particular, pension resources
were consistently used to support operating costs, pension
contribution holiday was taken and cost of retiree health care
was passed from the CTA's operating budget onto the pension
plan. Data show that the inadequate payments are unarguably
the sources of the problem since pension benefits are modest,
averaging just $1,920 a month.
Both CTA and the unions have made proposals to address the
funding crisis. CTA's "solution" switching to a defined
contribution pension would solve nothing because CTA would
have to run two systems, a costly process: CTA would legally
have to fulfill its existing obligations and could only place
new employees into the defined contribution system.
Furthermore, a study by the Illinois Retirement Security
Initiative shows that defined contribution systems have twice
the administrative cost of defined benefit systems and produce
less than 60 percent of the benefit levels of a defined
benefit system.
Without delay, the CTA and its unions must identify a
solution that adequately addresses the pension shortfall,
preserves the modest benefits of its current and future
retirees and is in line with the new transit-funding package.
Once that action has been taken, we can only hope that the
governor will sign the bill. Only our quality of life is at
stake.
Dia Cirillo
Policy Director
Workforce, Center for Tax and Budget
Accountability
Jourlande Gabriel
Director
Illinois Retirement Security Initiative
Chicago